Skip to Main Content
  • Old Anglers Inn logo top
    Old Anglers Inn logo scroll
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Live Music
  • Order
  • Private Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards
  • Go to top
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageGoogle page
Old Anglers Inn logo topOld Anglers Inn logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageGoogle page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Live Music
  • Order
  • Private Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Gift Cards

Our Menu

DinnerLunchOAI GARDENFathers Day

Raw Bar

ICE CHILLED OYSTERS

$25.00/6
$44.00/12
East Coast Wellfleet & West Coast Mirimichi

MAINE LOBSTER COCKTAIL

$32.00
Avocado, butter lettuce, poached lobster meat

SHRIMP COCKTAIL

$23.00
Jumbo 13/15, lemon, classic cocktail sauce, on ice

Sharables

ANCHOVIES & BRIOCHE

$19.00
Cultured butter, toasted brioche

BURRATA CROSTINI

$19.00
Blistered tomatoes, basil pesto, charred bread

OAI LOX ON BRIOCHE

$21.00
House-cured salmon, tzatziki, pickled onion, capers

Appetizers

BURRATA & TOMATOES photo

BURRATA & TOMATOES

$26.00
Heirloom tomatoes, Apulian burrata, basil, EVOO

CRAB STUFFED AVOCADO

$26.00
Lump crab, citrus, fleur de sel, lemon olive oil

SCALLOPS CARPACCIO

$29.00
Sungold kiwi, truffle vinaigrette, tomato-onion salsa

SQUASH BLOSSOM TEMPURA

$23.00
Ricotta-stuffed, yellow tomato coulis, sea salt

ARTICHOKES

$19.00
Baby artichokes, mint, white wine, ramp salsa verde

FAIRY TALE EGGPLANT

$21.00
Caponata-stuffed baby eggplant, basil aioli

Salads

BOSTON BIBB LETTUCE

$19.00
Avocado, tomato, radish, lemon-tarragon vinaigrette

GARDEN GREENS

$17.00
Radish, carrots, kiwi, basil, wine vinaigrette

CAESAR ROMAINE HEARTS

$19.00
Classic dressing, croutons, Parmigiano-Reggiano

STEAK TOMATOES

$21.00
Heirloom slices, red onion, basil, EVOO, Maldon

Entrees

MAINE LOBSTER BUCATINI

$54.00
Lemon bucatini, lobster meat, San Marzano tomato, lobster bisque

PAPPARDELLE

$30.00
White veal & mushroom ragu, Parmigiano

SOFT SHELL CRABS

$26.00/1
$49.00/2
Sautéed jumbo soft-shell, summer veg salad, capers, lemon aioli
ORA KING SALMON photo

ORA KING SALMON

$39.00
Summer squash, carrot-top basil pesto

SEA SCALLOPS

$45.00
Roasted cauliflower, herb oil

BONELESS HALF CHICKEN

$34.00
Brined, rosemary jus, ramps & oyster mushrooms
BEEF SHORT RIBS photo

BEEF SHORT RIBS

$45.00
Braised short rib, potato pavé, herb oil, red wine jus, horseradish
AMERICAN WAGYU PETITE FILET photo

AMERICAN WAGYU PETITE FILET

$46.00
Wagyu, blue cheese stuffed squash blossom, baby zucchini

LAMB RACK

$58.00
Frenched rack, rosemary jus, mint salsa verde, spring vegetables

DUCK BREAST

$46.00
Sour cherry sauce, fairy tale eggplant
ORECCHIETTE PRIMAVERA photo

ORECCHIETTE PRIMAVERA

$32.00
orecchiette pasta, summer vegetables, carrot-top basil pesto sauce parmigiano reggiano, toasted pinenuts

OAI WAGYU BURGER

$29.00
aged wagyu blend, caramelized onion, aged cheddar cheese, pickles, house fries or field green salad

Vegetables / Sides

PEAS A LA FRANCAISE

English peas, cipollini, prosciutto cotto, butter lettuce

POTATOES

Pavé and house crispy fries

ASPARAGUS

Butter, marcona almonds, lemon

BABY CARROTS

Tzatziki, carrot-top pesto, cumin

THIS MENU WILL BE AVAILABLE AS OF MAY 6 2026

SHARABLES / STARTERS

ANCHOVIES & BRIOCHE

$19.00
Cultured butter, toasted brioche

BURRATA CROSTINI

$19.00
Blistered tomatoes, basil pesto, charred bread

OAI LOX ON BRIOCHE

$20.00
House-cured salmon, tzatziki, pickled onion, capers

SQUASH BLOSSOM

$22.00
Ricotta-stuffed, yellow tomato coulis, sea salt

ARTICHOKES

$18.00
Baby artichokes, mint, white wine, ramp salsa verde

FAIRY TALE EGGPLANT

$20.00
Caponata-stuffed baby eggplant, basil aioli

BURRATA & TOMATOES

$24.00
Heirloom tomatoes, Apulian burrata, basil, EVOO

CRAB STUFFED AVOCADO

$25.00
Lump crab, citrus, fleur de sel, lemon olive oil

SCALLOPS CARPACCIO

$26.00
Sungold kiwi, truffle vinaigrette, tomato-onion salsa

SALADS

GARDEN GREENS

$17.00
Radish, carrots, kiwi, vinaigrette

CAESAR ROMAINE HEARTS

$18.00
Classic dressing, croutons, Parmigiano-Reggiano

STEAK TOMATOES

$19.00
Heirloom slices, red onion, basil, EVOO, Maldon
MAINE LOBSTER SALAD photo

MAINE LOBSTER SALAD

$32.00
Avocado, butter lettuce, poached lobster meat

SANDWICHES

OAI BURGER

$28.00
Wagyu, caramelized onion, sharp cheese, pickles, fries. 6 oz patty

OAI CLUB

$24.00
Triple-decker, prosciutto cotto, chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, fries

ENTRÉES

ORECCHIETTE PRIMAVERA

$25.00
Summer veg, carrot-top basil pesto, Parmigiano

PAPPARDELLE

$29.00
White veal & mushroom ragu, Parmigiano

ORA KING SALMON

$35.00
Summer squash, carrot-top basil pesto

SOFT SHELL CRABS

$23.00/1
$44.00/2
Sautéed jumbo soft-shell, summer veg salad, capers, lemon aioli

AMERICAN WAGYU PETITE FILET

$44.00
Wagyu, blue cheese stuffed squash blossom, baby zucchini

MAINE LOBSTER BUCATINI

$48.00
Lemon bucatini, lobster, San Marzano tomato, lobster bisque

VEGETABLES / SIDES

PEAS A LA FRANCAISE

$14.00
English peas, cipollini, prosciutto cotto, butter lettuce

POTATOES

$15.00
Potato pavé and house crispy fries

ASPARAGUS

$14.00
Butter, marcona almonds, lemon

BABY CARROTS

$14.00
Tzatziki, carrot-top pesto, cumin

THIS MENU WILL BE AVAILABLE AS OF MAY 6, 2026

TO SHARE

MARINATED OLIVES

$9.00
Mediterranean mix of olives & pickles
DIPS photo

DIPS

$18.00
Guacamole, hummus, whipped feta, house chips, corn chips

CEVICHE OF THE DAY

$21.00
Daily haddock, classic ceviche style

SMOKED FISH DIP

$19.00
House-smoked white fish, crostini

GRAINS SALAD

$21.00
Farro, chickpeas, quinoa, vegetables, herbs, lemon
WATERMELON & FETA photo

WATERMELON & FETA

$19.00
Watermelon, mint, Bulgarian feta, lemon olive oil

BAVARIAN PRETZEL

$18.00
Salt or cinnamon, beer cheese or Zatarain’s creole mustard

SNACKS / MAINS

CHICKEN WINGS

$15.00/6
$28.00/12
Crispy Buffalo style

AOI CHICKEN WRAP

$21.00
Grilled chicken breast, sharp provolone, tomato, lettuce, house aioli

PULLED PORK SANDWICH

$24.00
Slow-cooked pork shoulder, BBQ sauce, slaw, pickles

AOI BURGER

$22.00
American cheese, spicy smoked aioli, pickles, chips. 2 x 4 oz patties

KOBE BEEF HOT DOG

$18.00
12-inch Wagyu hot dog, mustard, slaw, chips

BRATWURST

$18.00
Pickled slaw, spicy smoked aioli, chips

PIZZA

MARGHERITA

$25.00
Mutti tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, EVOO
PEPPERONI photo

PEPPERONI

$27.00
Crispy pepperoni, mozzarella, Mutti tomato

DIAVOLO

$27.00
Sausage, pepperoni, Calabrian chili, mozzarella, Mutti

KIDS

CHEESEBURGER

$14.00
Single 4 oz patty, American cheese, bun

HOT DOG

$14.00
Kids hot dog, bun

IN ADDITION TO OUR REGULAR MENUS WE ARE OFFERING THESE DAD INSPIRED, CHEF CREATIONS

Starters

WE ARE OFFERING IN ADDITION TO OUR REGULAR MENUS THE FOLLOWING STARTERS

Seafood Tower

$155.00/2ppl
$265.00/4ppl
Collection of seafood inspired by the mediterranean coasts

Wild Rhode Island Calamari

$34.00
1 lb Grilled fresh rhode island calamari, lemon, olive oil, smoked paprika

Main

CHOOSE FROM OUR CHEF'S FATHER'S DAY SELECTION OF MAIN COURSES OR ONE OF YOUR FAVORITES ON OUR REGULAR MENUS. ITS YOUR CHOICE DAD!

Catelli Veal Chop

$76.00
16oz roasted veal chop , potato napoleon, baby carrots, veal au jus reduction

Angus Beef Ribeye

$71.00
12oz Angus beef ribeye , maitre d'hotel butter, charred broccolini , red wine beef sauce

Whole Wild Danish Dover Sole

$95.00
1LB Whole wild dover sole, lemon butter sauce, asparagus almondine
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs